Stop Playing Vibes Like a Magic Player by Chonkeroo

Cantrip: The most overused term in Magic: the Gathering.
a cantrip is a low-cost spell—usually 0 to 1 mana—that provides a minor effect and replaces itself in your hand by including a "draw a card" clause.
Card advantage has been the cornerstone of winning TCG's since dinosaurs like me have started playing TCG's in the 90's. (Maybe earlier but I can't vouch for that)
In MTG the goal has always been to draw cards. Having cards that replace themselves, or cantrip, has always been the premier way to gain an advantage in a game. Vibes is about to change all of that.
A few hours ago I lost to @cautionfun_ in the semi-finals of @scgcon Hartford. We were both playing Red/Purple shells with a handful of differences. My version opted the tried-and-true card draw, card advantage, while his version sought to gain advantage through attrition and resource denial.
I believe I've been outclassed.
In MTG killing (or icing) a creature deprives the owner of that creature and its abilities. In Vibes icing a character deprives the owner of a permanent, the pudge it could produce, the ability it provides, and gains the same advantage as a cantrip - cards replacing themselves or netting you a card against your opponent.
My magic brain has spent so much energy in Vibes looking for ways to draw cards to gain an advantage that it didn't look at the much more obvious solution: Can I get recurring removal to net cards instead of simply drawing cards? @themudman_gu and Caution Fun figured this out before me.
Keeping your opponent off resources is much more valuable than drawing cards. You net the same amount of card advantage, while depriving them of resources.
While this might seem obvious as I'm explaining it - it's not intuitive to Magic players who have been told to draw cards their whole lives.
So what does this mean for the future of deck building?
1.) Removal is far more valuable than card draw will ever be.
It is incorrect to value things like Study All Day over any form of removal. While cards like Relaxing Birb and Study All Day can net you an incredible advantage, they aren't simultaneously threats and answers. Deck building will evolve to favor things like Iron Penguin and Sudsy Birb, etc. over any form of things that simply draw cards.
2.) Attrition-based decks will always be more effective than go-wide decks.
Buddy Up is a very powerful threat. It can feel unfair when you're crushing your opponent and out of nowhere, they Buddy Up and win the game. However, those victories pale in comparison to the number of games Popcorn Penguin has completely shutdown a go-wide deck. That's because attrition-based advantage is infinitely more valuable than simply drawing cards.
I don't have a deck built for this article, nor do I think it's worth it to develop a format when we don't have any more events before a new set. However, what I will promise you is this: The future of Vibes will be VERY destructive to your board state. Preventing your opponent from playing the game will prove to be a much better strategy than "outdrawing" them.
Big Congrats to Caution Fun for his victory in Hartford! I can't wait to start playing with Set Four, Table for Two! See you all this week for @whatnot and @twitch fun!
With Love,
Chonkeroo





